6 Questions to Ask When Choosing a Fiduciary

Nov 13, 2026Elder Law

6 Questions to Ask When Choosing a Fiduciary

What is a Fiduciary?

Choosing decision-makers can be difficult. Family conflict, geographic distance, a lack of available relatives, or a lack of a support network may mean a family member or close friend is not the best choice. Even someone you trust personally could lack the time, experience, organization, or willingness required to serve effectively. An estate planning attorney can help you evaluate your options and determine who may be best suited for these important roles.

Many of the individuals appointed to manage your property or financial affairs, such as trustees, personal representatives, and agents under financial powers of attorney, serve as fiduciaries. A fiduciary has a legal duty to act in accordance with the governing document and applicable law. This includes duties to act loyally, carefully, and in the interests of the person or beneficiaries they serve.

When a suitable friend or family member is unavailable, hiring a professional fiduciary may provide clients with experience, neutrality, and continuity. However, not every professional offers the same qualifications, services, or fee structure. Asking the right questions can help you determine whether a prospective fiduciary is qualified, trustworthy, and well suited to carry out your wishes.

A comprehensive estate plan does more than direct who will receive your money and property after your death. It also provides instructions for managing your affairs during your lifetime and identifies the people who will act for you if you are unable to act. An effective plan generally does the following:

  • Outlines your wishes for managing and distributing your money and property during your lifetime and after your death
  • Documents your healthcare preferences if you become unable to make or communicate medical decisions
  • Designates trusted individuals to carry out financial, legal, and healthcare decisions on your behalf

Financial Decision-Makers in an Estate Plan

1. Executor or personal representative

This person administers your estate after your death in accordance with your estate plan, applicable probate law, and court requirements. They collect and manage estate assets, pay valid debts and expenses, and complete required filings. They then distribute the remaining property to your beneficiaries or trustee according to your estate plan and other applicable laws.

2. Initial trustee of a revocable living trust

The initial trustee is the person who manages the trust when it is first created. In many revocable living trusts, the person creating the trust also serves as the initial trustee, allowing them to continue managing and using the trust property during their lifetime. The initial trustee serves until they become unable to serve, or another event specified in the trust occurs. At that point, the successor trustee steps in to manage the trust according to its terms.

3. Successor trustee of a revocable living trust (if applicable)

This person takes over management of the trust when the current trustee dies, resigns, or becomes unable to serve. Depending on the circumstances and the trust’s terms, the successor trustee may manage and use trust property for your benefit during your lifetime and distribute the remaining property to your beneficiaries after your death.

4. Agent under a financial power of attorney

This agent conducts authorized financial and legal transactions on your behalf, such as managing accounts, paying bills, or signing documents. The scope of the agent’s authority and when it becomes effective are governed by the power of attorney and applicable state law.

5. Professional Fiduciaries

When selecting an agent to handle your financial transactions, several options may be available to you beyond family and friends.

  • Ask if your bank or financial institution has a trust department. Because they are already familiar with managing your accounts, they may be a good fit to step in and assist you if needed.
  • Interview a private trust company that specializes in managing money on behalf of individuals. They are likely well-equipped to handle the administrative tasks associated with being a financial decision-maker.
  • Consider asking your certified public accountant (CPA) or financial advisor if they are willing to act on your behalf or if they know someone who can.

After a consultation, an estate planning lawyer can help you evaluate which options best fit your situation.

Questions to Ask a Professional Fiduciary

When interviewing potential candidates, consider asking the following questions:

1. How do you charge for your services?

Ask whether fees are hourly, based on a percentage of the assets, subject to a minimum, or calculated another way. Additionally, inquire about additional expenses to understand how the total cost may affect your estate or beneficiaries.

2. How do you document the transactions you conduct, and who may access those records?

Careful record-keeping and appropriate transparency help ensure accountability while protecting sensitive financial information. Proper documentation can help prevent future estate disputes.

3. How long does it typically take to administer an estate or trust of this size and complexity?

Although timing depends on the circumstances, the answer can help you evaluate the fiduciary’s experience, workload, and approach to resolving matters efficiently without sacrificing accuracy.

4. How often do you communicate with the beneficiaries and my family members?

It is important that everyone is on the same page and that lines of communication remain open to help avoid potential conflicts after you pass away.

5. Do you require specific provisions in the estate planning documents or any additional paperwork before agreeing to serve?

Your estate planning attorney should review these requirements to ensure your documents grant the necessary authority and will operate as intended when the fiduciary takes over.

6. What have been your most successful and most challenging experiences administering an estate or a trust?

The response may reveal how the fiduciary approaches difficult situations, communicates with beneficiaries, resolves conflicts, and defines a successful administration. It can also help you determine whether the professional’s experience and working style align with your needs.

Personal Care Decision-Makers

These roles often feel like the most difficult to fill. You are asking someone to look after your safety and welfare as well as that of any pets you may have. Accordingly, each role has unique considerations:

Agent under a medical power of attorney

This agent makes or communicates your medical wishes if you become unable to make or communicate them yourself. In addition to appointing an agent, consider completing an advance directive or living will with the assistance of your estate planning attorney. These documents can communicate your treatment preferences to your agent and healthcare providers.

You may also wish to prepare a letter of instruction explaining, in your own words, the types of treatment you would or would not want. Although such a letter may not carry the same legal authority as an advance directive, it can provide valuable guidance when difficult or unexpected decisions arise.

If you do not have a suitable family member, you may consider appointing a trusted friend or, where permitted, a qualified professional. State law may prohibit certain individuals, including some healthcare providers or employees of healthcare facilities, from serving unless an exception applies.

Future caretaker for your pet

This person provides a safe and loving home for your pet if you become unable to care for them. Because the law generally treats animals as personal property, simply expressing your wishes may not be enough. Speak with the proposed caretaker in advance to confirm that the person is willing and able to serve, and consider providing funds and written instructions for your pet’s ongoing care.

If no family member or friend is suitable, certain animal welfare organizations, veterinary programs, or foundations may be able to care for your pet or help identify an appropriate permanent home. Any arrangement should be confirmed with the organization in advance and properly incorporated into your estate plan.

Questions to Ask Personal Care Decision-Makers

When interviewing potential candidates for your personal care decision-makers, consider asking the following questions:

Do you charge for your services?

Some professionals and organizations charge fees, while friends or family members may not. Knowing the anticipated cost helps you set aside enough funds and decide how you’ll pay.

When and how should you be contacted if your assistance is needed?

Since you don’t know when you will need their assistance and won’t be the one contacting them, make sure someone can easily contact them in an emergency.

Is there additional information or paperwork needed to carry out your role?

Confirm that the person or organization has, or knows how to access, the necessary legal documents, contact information, medical preferences, pet-care instructions, and other relevant records before an emergency occurs.

Choosing the Right Fiduciary for Your Estate Plan

Uncertainty about whom to appoint to these important roles can delay the estate planning process, but it should not prevent you from moving forward. While even a complete estate plan can’t prevent all heir or family disputes, fiduciary selection can reduce confusion and conflict. These appointments do not determine whether your estate will enter probate.

Our estate planning services help clients evaluate their options, identify appropriate decision-makers, and create a plan that protects them and those they care about. When you have estate planning needs, look no further than the J. L. Williamson Law Group. With a track record of happy clients, our lawyers are here to answer your questions about estate planning.

Jeffrey Williamson, Founder headshot

About the Author

Jeffrey L. Williamson | Founder

Jeffrey L. Williamson is the founder of J. L. Williamson Law Group, LLC. The Firm specializes in asset protection, elder law, tax planning, and tax controversy.